Trust Deficit Between the Government and the People – A Potential Danger to the Nation – By H. R. Bapu Satyanarayana

Background

A survey of what is happening on the national scene gives a very alarming foreboding for the future of India.  It appears the country is hurtling headlong into a situation that holds a potential for imploding with catastrophic consequences to its stability and integrity.  The television or print media, internet or cinema are full of negative happenings in the society – unchecked corruption, murders, rape in all its depravity, divorce, honour killings, religious polarization, etc. which send disturbing signals as to where our society is heading.  We pride ourselves as the world’s largest parliamentary democracy with a written constitution that enshrines the best features taken from other countries. As the country progressed, we have incorporated more than 100 amendments to our constitution to adapt to the changing situation in the larger interest of governance and to build an equitable and inclusive society.

For a country which is now  in its 69th year of independence, comparatively young, the progress achievement whether in food production, education, science and technology, space exploration, nuclear technology, communication, etc. is enviable.  We are presently poised to join the ranks of developed countries of the world.  There is another face of India that is singularly striking.  We have the unique record of not invading any country; on the contrary, we have been ravished by hordes of invaders for centuries and yet the strength of our 5000 years of cultural heritage and values was such that those who came as invaders got assimilated into the mainstream of life. Though comparison may be odious, it is disquieting to see how smaller countries like Singapore or Japan have made long strides in a short period, while with lot of potential, India with all progress made appears to be a failed state. Here lies the paradox as though India is living at two levels divorced from reality for what is generally construed as achievement of progress is only a surface phenomenon and misleading.

For example, our diaspora spread across the world has an envious record. To cite the statistics: 38% of doctors in US are Indians, 34% of NASA scientists are Indians, 34% of Microsoft employees are Indians, 28% of IBM employees are Indians,17% of Intel employees are Indians and 12% of total scientists in US are Indians.  Therefore, it strikes me odd that it is the same educated Indians blessed with the same brain power are, in larger numbers, in India and yet the country has failed to marshal their potential.  When analysed, our democracy has become fragile and is in danger of crumbling into anarchy with unpredictable consequences. There are many issues seemingly intractable that confront India and each one of them, when not handled wisely and firmly by the political establishments, has a potential to spiral out of control to engulf the nation in political and economic chaos.  Currently, India faces its toughest test of existential reality of its democratic credentials .Unless the political rulers and the opposition rise above petty politics for personal gain, demonstrate their statesmanship to confront the economic and social challenges the country faces and work in the larger interest of the country, all  the gains made till now may be seriously compromised, besides exposing the country as an easy target  for inimical forces to strike.

Here are some instances of problems that India faces.

Wash out of the Monsoon Session

Perhaps in the history of parliamentary democracy, the recently concluded monsoon session ended without any major bill passed.  It was apparent from day one the main opposition party Congress appeared determined not to let the parliament function. It was marked by frequent disruption of the session – both houses of the parliament rushing into the well of the House shouting away and tearing papers.  The speaker known for her exemplary patience was forced to dismiss 25 MPs  from attending the House for five days.  It is a matter of shame for the country that MPs misbehaved in front of a gallery of important visitors from other countries.

Some important and urgent bills like the reformation bill on Goods and Services and the contentious bill on Land Acquisition had to be shelved.

Protest by military veterans on OROP issue

Our Indian Army is known world over for their bravery, discipline and fighting qualities. They have demonstrated their military prowess in three wars fought against Pakistan where our brave jawans sacrificed their lives.  The jawans are subjected daily to cross-border firing in J&K besides fighting the terrorists infiltrating the border. This has resulted in both civilian and military casualties.  Our military veterans who, during their active service fought for the security of the country, and the widows of those who laid down their lives for the country, are unable to lead a dignified life owing to poor pension benefits.  It is in this context our veterans are asking the government to implement One Rank One Pension (OROP) which will give pension regardless of when they retired so that they can get adequate pension to lead a comfortable life.

Protest for reservation for Patels in Gujarat

The reservation has a chequered history. The definitive beginning was when the Mandal Commission was established in 1979 during the Janata Party rule under Morarji Desai. Its recommendation was all but forgotten and was revived when V. P. Singh became prime minister and his position was threatened. It took a dramatic turn when a student, Rajiv Goswami immolated himself in October 1990.  Presently, it stands with the Supreme Court limiting the reservation to 50%. This has thrown up a different dimension with each and every caste protesting, from time to time, in a competitive bid to gain the ‘backward community’ tag trying to claim a share in the pie.  Reservation has become a contentious issue with political parties reducing it to vote bank politics.

The latest incarnation is the emergence of a middle class, well-employed  22 year old Hardik Patel agitating for reservation status for his community. His agitation claimed nine lives after his arrest and seems to throw a new dimension to the reservation policy. In his interview to The Hindu on August 27, 2015 he says: ‘Our people don’t get jobs despite scoring 80-90 percent marks, so they are forced to do their own business, because of reservation system’.

Meanwhile, M. G. Vaidya, RSS ideologue says that caste based quota should be abolished.  This development may trigger an anti-reservation policy.  This is going to result in political turbulence for the implied message in Hardik’s agitation is also abolition of caste-based reservation since merit is ignored.  Meritorious people, particularly in forward-looking communities will welcome this agitation as this skewed reservation policy has acted against merit.  Hopefully, the reservation policy will get a new look so that economic backwardness would be the criteria, and not caste.

Litterateur M. M. Kalburgi shot dead in Karnataka

In a heinous crime, a scholar and a star in the literary field, M. M. Kalburgi was shot dead by unidentified persons posing as his students in his home in Dharwad on August 30, 2015.  His killing has been widely condemned.  He was known for his outspoken attitude which landed him in controversy several times. It is possible he may have made enemies as evidenced by some rabid persons who gloated over his killing and warned others of his own ilk.  The government has tightened security for such persons.

This raises a pertinent question – to what extent freedom of speech prevails.  Our Constitution gives us the right to freedom of speech and it is equally important to exercise that right wisely.  We seem to be not living in normal times; tolerance and patience appear to be in short supply.  It reminds me of Mr. Nani Palkhivala’s comment “I think we Indians have too much of independence” when asked for his thought on India’s 50th year of independence.  There are other two statements worth quoting – the French writer and philosopher, Voltaire who says “I do not agree with what you have to say, but I’ll defend  to the death your right to say it.”  And, a Sanskrit saying which goes like this – Priyam bhruyat, satyam bhruyat, na bhruyat satyam appriyam which roughly means – always tell what is pleasant, what is true, but do not utter truth that is not palatable.  I hope the killers of Kalburgi are caught and punished.

Tribal protest in Manipur                

Lack of clarity in explaining the objective of passing the Manipur Peoples Bill, 2015 and the two amendments by the Manipur Government which were interpreted as ‘anti-tribal’ led to protests by students which, unfortunately, took the life of five persons and injured many.  The fact that the Chief Minister’s house was targeted and houses of four MLAs were set on fire shows a deeper malaise that has gripped not only Manipur, but indicates a general feeling of rebellion against the government.  This feeling seems to be spreading across the country where a small incident acts as a trigger and explodes into a rage with unpredictable aftermath.  It shows the governments are not only unresponsive to the aspirations of the people but also exhibits an arrogance of power.

Conclusion

The above issues point out to an atmosphere of rebellion building up for years against the authorities everywhere. The reason is that the general public remains a silent witness to the inequity in the system where corruption and money power have a stranglehold, subverting all institutions, to serve their selfish aims.  Government policies are designed to create caste and religious differences and help retain power with vote bank politics.  Once elected, the majority of MPs and MLAs forget that they are peoples’ representatives and behave like potentates enjoying all kinds of privileges, while the aam admi suffers untold miseries.  Successive elections, a symbol of democracy, have failed to deliver justice as only the corrupt get elected in election after election.  The rash of protests erupting all over shows the people’s disenchantment witnessing the arrogance of power.  The present situation is a warning to the governments to reform themselves, or else the silent rage building up may burst enveloping the nation with disastrous consequences.

Mr. H. R. Bapu Satyanarayana is a freelance writer based at Mysore.  E-mail: what_option@yahoo.co.in

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Trust Deficit Between the Government and the People – A Potential Danger to the Nation – By H. R. Bapu Satyanarayana

  1. If any institution is not doing well, it is necessary to change the top managers.
    The same is true of India. We need better MPs MLAs and ministers. At present these ranks are filled mostly by corrupt incompetent and criminal persons because they are expert in winning in our “first past the post” elections. We need a change in our election system to elect better manpower to manage our country. The “PARTY-LIST PROPORTIOAL REPRESENTATION” will be the most suitable electoral system for India.

    Like

  2. Mr. Bapu has rightly analysed, as below, the causes of ills of our country:”………..It shows the governments are not only unresponsive to the aspirations of the people but also exhibits an arrogance of power.” Please go back a little and we can find a big leadership gap in our country. Ever since the departure of Lal Bahadur Shastri, we didn’t have a statesman like figure at the helm of affairs of the state to steer the country of its growing morass. And the continued absence of inspiring leadership ensured our country’s downslide in all walks of life descending in to corruption, lawlessness, misgovernance and what not, with dubious distinctions galore. But i can see not all hope is lost. If a tiny country like Tunisia could produce 4 Nobel Laureates, called Tunisian National Dialogue Quartet, in one go, for reviving democracy from out of prolonged tyrannical dictatorships, why not India of more than one billion people can produce at least one leader in the years to come to put it back on the rails?

    Like

    • I entirely agree and personally I am an optimist and present govt has inherited a difficult legacy when systematically all institutions were subverted to perpetuate a dynastic hold and even now we can see how biased almost all English media who are completely blind to the several initiatives that have been taken by the present NDA Govt and hopefully wiser counsels assert to remove the negative perception.Presently the opposition led by the Congress is systematically spreading all sorts of canards and when results starts trickling perhaps the mood in the country will cahnge.
      H.R.Bapu Satyanarayan

      Like

      • Here is the latest sample for arrogance of power of a Minister

        Oct 24 2015 : Mirror (Mumbai)
        CITY BRIEF
        PTI
        
        
        URGENT MATTERS WON’T BE KEPT ON HOLD FOR YOU, HIGH COURT TELLS `BUSY’ MINISTER OF STATE

        The Bombay High Court has taken a serious view of the stand taken by a Maharashtra minister that he will not be available until January 2016 to hear an appeal filed by a cooperative society.

        The appeal -which had been filed before the appellate authority (Minister) -had challenged the supersession of the society’s managing committee and appointment of administrative officer in its place to manage the affairs.

        “We do not countenance such state of affairs.Even if appellate authority is a Minister of State in the government of Maharashtra, does not mean that urgent matters are kept on hold for his or her nonavailability,“ said justices S C Dharmadhikari and B P Colabawala in their order.

        “If quasijudicial powers are vested in the ministers to decide matters which are as serious as appeals, then, they have to find time to perform such duties,“ the judges said. “In the facts peculiar to this case and looking to the urgency, we direct that the application for stay filed by the petitioners shall be taken up by Secretary in the Department of Cooperation and Textiles who shall, after hearing both sides, pass a reasoned order thereon as expeditiously as pos sible on or before October 30,“ the court ordered.

        The court, while disposing of the petition, asked the society to appear before the secretary concerned on October 23 (today) and ruled that all contentions of both sides are kept open. The bench noted, “We are not concerned with how officers exercising powers under different statutes proceeded to sanction and implement the slum rehabilitation scheme on a plot of land. But we are concerned here with the cooperative housing society.“

        The SRA officers have powers to initiate proceedings under sections 78 and 78A of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act. Accordingly, an order dated September 9, 2015, was passed superseding the managing committee and appointing an administrator to manage the affairs of the society.

        Against this order, the petitioners approached the appellate authority by filing an appeal which is pending. Since the petitioners were served with a communication that the administrator was to take charge of the affairs of the petitioner-society from October 5, the aggrieved society approached the appellate authority (the Minister of State for cooperation) with an application for interim stay.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s